Jump to content
Cornwall Football Forum
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt

Recommended Posts

Will be interesting to get further guidance when available if all dissent will be dealt with?

Swearing outload to yourself, swearing at an opponent, team mate, referee, management, how far does this go?

Answer is dont swear, but easier said than done! 

We know the part management and players need to play in this, but referees (who all dont officiate in the same manner) will soon be called to task on how strict the implementation of this goes!

Im guessing a good trial run would be pre season for clubs and match officials alike?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Nick Pope said:

So things like constant moaning to the ref... what other examples are there?

It did cross my mind about foul and abusive being a red so that clears that up🔴

Slamming the ball down when a free-kick/throw-in is awarded against a decision. Moaning at the referee but, not using OFFINABUS language. It is in the opinion of the referee though so each will have slightly different opinions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Foul & Abusive has been a red card for many years.When The FA tried to highlight this many years ago, I can remember Refs coming into dressing rooms pre match & saying “No jewellery or swearing “.

Trouble is not enough refs had the balls to enforce this. It is far easier to hand out 2 yellows for pathetic offences, against which there is no appeal, go home press a button on the computer. No report required, job done !

Who would be a club football secretary or player these days.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Basically,  it's the old Caution for Dissent  towards Referee or Assistant Referee (C2). 

You have to play with 10 men for 10 minutes while he sits down and calms down.

Rather than a £10 fine in the post on Monday, the team suffers. Especially in the last 10 minutes of the game because that, in effect, is game over for that player. I'm not sure what the fines or points are to the Club.

It's harder to enforce in the Duchy League as there may not be dugouts and perimeter fences etc but I am starting to get used to it. 

Players will take a lot of getting used to it but I am ok with it. It works better when you use 'rolling subs' so not sure how popular it will be on swpl. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

How is the 'sin bin' going to work, I can see enormous problems for match officals, players, club linesmen etc. It would be nice to see the views of the match officials who seem to be in favour or have not made much objection to it through their association.

1. Who will actually keep the time the player is off the pitch ?

2. Can a player be sent to the bin just before the end - what happens to the remaining minutes, do they carry over ?

3. Does the time in the bin only count when the ball is in play ? ( Has to be otherwise players will be falling over more than now)

4. If so how do you keep a record of the time in the bin, every time that play is stopped ?

5. How on earth would a match official keep the times of several players off the pitch at the same time, plus different stoppage time to be added to those players.

6. You could have match officials with several watches on their arms or use clocks from chess games :yahoo:

7. With all these problems and many more it would be so difficult for match officials to send off more than one at one time, they would not want to do it and unless some form of help with the timing is devised they wont do it.

8. Must have been thought up by these graduate entries that the FA have at Wembly, never kicked a ball in their lives.

Dear o dear what has it come to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Sin Bin is only for dissent so Home Waters ensure your players don’t offend and the ref won’t have any problems! 

The FA are delivering training to Step 5 and 6 clubs and Level 4 referees.

If a player is binned with less than 10 minutes remaining, the sin bin expires. It’s not carried over to the next match, if you get sin binned with 5 minutes left then you only miss 5 minutes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
43 minutes ago, Dave Deacon said:

The Sin Bin is only for dissent so Home Waters ensure your players don’t offend and the ref won’t have any problems! 

The FA are delivering training to Step 5 and 6 clubs and Level 4 referees.

If a player is binned with less than 10 minutes remaining, the sin bin expires. It’s not carried over to the next match, if you get sin binned with 5 minutes left then you only miss 5 minutes

You obviously don't get the point - its only when the ball is in play that time in the bin counts - how will the referee keep the time for each different player that is off - having never been to a match in over half a century without dissent at one point or another, you are very naive Dave, to argue that the system will only work if there's no dissent, is not an argument to say it will work.

What if the keeper is sent off - then I presume a remaining outfield player can be substituted by the reserve keeper, then when he is back do a reverse substitution.

You havn't answered any of the questions at all really and  TOIGTBIW just to say the crowd will let him know is rather silly to say the least.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Was already waiting for the objections to kick off here! Sin Bin has trialled extremely well at Duchy level and the officials have used it very well. The simple fact is it puts the onus on individual players to control themselves. If a player turns to the ref and cries "what are you playing at, how can you give that, etc" and otherwise throws his toys out the proverbial pram then hes off for 10 mins minimum. Simple. Not the refs fault, just the players. Managers will need to educate their players and dissent at the official has no defence. Or perhaps people can make a defence for dissent here......Still technically a yellow so still accumulates disciplinary points but no fine to pay. At our level our assistants always ask the ref if they want a hand timekeeping any sinbins but ultimately the call is the refs. Hardly any games this season have seen more than one player binned at a time btw. 10 mins starts once the offender has crossed the touchline and it's a minimum 10 mins which can extend at the refs call in the event of deliberate timewasting. Bins less than 10mins before half time do carry over to the 2nd half. An outfield player can don the gloves if a keeper gets binned but unless there is rolling subs in use then he cant be temporarily subbed. Binned players also need to be kept in a designated area for the time which the ref can specify prior to kick off....

Dissent is well down at Duchy level since its introduction..having seen several SWPL fixtures this season it's high time this was brought into the higher levels of the game. 

Worth mentioning too that the CCFA and FA were very helpful to clubs prior to to its introduction...all the questions get fully explained and answered if asked

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Home Waters said:

You obviously don't get the point - its only when the ball is in play TOIGTBIW just to say the crowd will let him know is rather silly to say the least.

 

Think about it, do you think the manager and spectators will not keep reminding him ?

 

Of course they will....endlessly! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure how many players you’re expecting in the bin at the same time!

The stats rolled out in the Duchy and Trelawny League training suggested that the number of yellow cards given for dissent was actually very low anyway.

The Sin Bin idea for dissent would of course work if the players kept their mouths shut in the first place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Dave Deacon said:

Not sure how many players you’re expecting in the bin at the same time!

The stats rolled out in the Duchy and Trelawny League training suggested that the number of yellow cards given for dissent was actually very low anyway.

The Sin Bin idea for dissent would of course work if the players kept their mouths shut in the first place.

WHAT! keep their mouths shut...their opinions would choke them..lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Countyman - you don't need rolling subs to do the swop - keeper comes off - sub please ref - among the five named subs is a keeper - take off the centre forward and keeper two goes in goal - when time is up - sinned keeper goes back on in goal - club say sub please ref - take off the sub that went on and replace him with another named sub. At least then the club has kept a 'keeper' on the field, but lost a player they may not have intended to sub during the game, or they may have.

I fully accept its the players fault, of course, but that doesn't make the system that is going to punish them an efficient system and easy for match officals to carry out, easy for players left on the field to try and circumnavigate the time gap.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Home Waters said:

You obviously don't get the point - its only when the ball is in play that time in the bin counts - how will the referee keep the time for each different player that is off - having never been to a match in over half a century without dissent at one point or another, you are very naive Dave, to argue that the system will only work if there's no dissent, is not an argument to say it will work.

What if the keeper is sent off - then I presume a remaining outfield player can be substituted by the reserve keeper, then when he is back do a reverse substitution.

You havn't answered any of the questions at all really and  TOIGTBIW just to say the crowd will let him know is rather silly to say the least.

 

The time isn’t ball in play, but 10 minutes playing time. So the stoppages will be the same if more than one in the bin. 

 

Also write down time in bin, can’t be too hard to remember time back on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, bighairydave said:

The time isn’t ball in play, but 10 minutes playing time. So the stoppages will be the same if more than one in the bin. 

 

Also write down time in bin, can’t be too hard to remember time back on.

The point I am trying to make, not very successfully, is that wasting time becomes more professional the higher up the pyramid you climb. So if its playing time and not ball in play that counts, then some teams at our level are experts at wasting time from the kick off, until a goal is scored against them. With goal kicks and throw ins wasting enormous time. Re more than one player off, don't assume that two players are sent off at the same time, there could be two or more players sent off within that ten minute period, try tracking those times.. The higher up the pyramid you climb, the more professional a club becomes, training, coaching staff,etc who will be busy devising delays during the ten minutes. If the FA are so confident why didn't they start at the top of the pyramid.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have used this system in the 2 year trials in the Duchy League and Junior Cup - so hopefully these answer your queries.  Does it work, i hear you ask - sometimes is the answer.  

If clubs embrace it then yes, it works, if not it can be something else to berate the officials - Roll on next season with the red and yellow cards for all Managers etc on the bench.

The most players I've sent to the sin bin at any one time is 2, with the most ive used it it a game is 3

Only Players on the actual pitch can be sent to the sin bin - substitutes on the bench receive a standard yellow card.

Hope this helps

Rob

On 18/03/2019 at 10:53, Home Waters said:

How is the 'sin bin' going to work, I can see enormous problems for match officals, players, club linesmen etc. It would be nice to see the views of the match officials who seem to be in favour or have not made much objection to it through their association.

1. Who will actually keep the time the player is off the pitch ?    -  The Referee

2. Can a player be sent to the bin just before the end - what happens to the remaining minutes, do they carry over ?   -  Yes he can - Will only carry over into extra time if in a cup match (but is cancelled before Kicks from the Penalty Mark - so the player can take their kick) and do not carry on to further matches

3. Does the time in the bin only count when the ball is in play ? ( Has to be otherwise players will be falling over more than now) - If the referee stops the watch for the game - ie time wasting, lost ball etc, then the sin bin watch stops as well

4. If so how do you keep a record of the time in the bin, every time that play is stopped ?  Easy - make a note of the game time (e.g. 33rd minute) that the player is sin-binned.  Add 10 minutes to that - when the watch reaches that time the referee can call the player back on - or the referee can use a smart watch with the REFSIX app and it does it all for you

5. How on earth would a match official keep the times of several players off the pitch at the same time, plus different stoppage time to be added to those players. - Use the above method - its not too bad really - can just check the times when the ball is out of play if needed

6. You could have match officials with several watches on their arms or use clocks from chess games :yahoo:only need the standard number of watches

7. With all these problems and many more it would be so difficult for match officials to send off more than one at one time, they would not want to do it and unless some form of help with the timing is devised they wont do it.  - If the clubs control their players on the pitch, and the players control themselves there will be no need to implement it.  It will take a bit of time, and hopefully the FA will work with the level 4 referees and the clubs to try and get a consistent approach

8. Must have been thought up by these graduate entries that the FA have at Wembly, never kicked a ball in their lives.    -  it has been implemented by IFAB and FIFA in consultation with stakeholders in football from around the world, to try something to remove dissent from the game.  Unfortunately, society in general, shows a lack of respect to any and all authority figures 

Dear o dear what has it come to.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Robin Tucker said:

I have used this system in the 2 year trials in the Duchy League and Junior Cup - so hopefully these answer your queries.  Does it work, i hear you ask - sometimes is the answer.  

If clubs embrace it then yes, it works, if not it can be something else to berate the officials - Roll on next season with the red and yellow cards for all Managers etc on the bench.

The most players I've sent to the sin bin at any one time is 2, with the most ive used it it a game is 3

Only Players on the actual pitch can be sent to the sin bin - substitutes on the bench receive a standard yellow card.

Hope this helps

Rob

 

Thank you very much for a detailed theoretical explanation, be interesting how the bigger boys deal with it !!!!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...